Business Models on the Edge of Regulation

Innovation vs. Regulation: Are you operating in the grey zone of the financial market?
Ambition and innovation drive progress, but they clash with the world of financial regulation, which operates at a different pace and on different principles. The main task of the CNB (Czech National Bank) is to protect the stability of the financial system and, above all, investors, especially the less experienced, i.e., retail investors.
Many entrepreneurs mistakenly believe that if there is no specific law for their particular model, they are operating in a safe "grey zone." However, this is a dangerous misconception. The CNB does not wait for new legislation; it applies the substance and purpose of existing laws, especially the Act on Investment Companies and Investment Funds (ZISIF), to new business models. It is therefore not about what you name your product, but what its actual economic substance is.
The real conflict, therefore, does not lie in a battle of "business against bureaucracy," but in the confrontation of "uninformed risk against strategic structuring." CNB's procedures are predictable if you understand its core principles, which are repeatedly reflected in its opinions and decisions. The risk is not regulation itself, but ignorance of it.
A proactive and legally sound approach is thus not a cost, but a competitive advantage that allows for the creation of an innovative model that is simultaneously seamless for the regulator.
The Czech legal team at ARROWS specializes in analyzing these "grey zones" and helping clients understand exactly where the boundaries of legal business lie.
What is an "unlicensed fund" and why should you care?
The term "unlicensed fund" may sound archaic, but its definition under Czech legislation in Section 98 of ZISIF is very modern and applies to a wide range of activities. For your business model to be classified as an unlicensed fund, it must cumulatively, i.e., simultaneously, meet all three of the following criteria:
Gathering funds from the "public": The threshold for who is considered the "public" is surprisingly low. The law does not define the term "public" and the CNB interprets it broadly; the decisive factor is whether the offer is addressed to an unspecified circle of persons, not the specific number of people contacted. It is completely irrelevant what legal form you choose to collect the money – it can be the sale of shares, silent partnership agreements, loans, or other agreements. The decisive factor is the economic purpose: to obtain capital for joint investment.
For the purpose of joint investment: This criterion is met if funds from multiple investors are managed under a single investment strategy and the investors jointly share the return and risk. Even if investors select specific projects on a platform, but the platform operator manages these funds as a whole, it can be considered joint investment. In such a model, the investor has no control over the day-to-day management of the investment.
Dependence of the return on asset performance (so-called market risk): This is the most fundamental and often misunderstood criterion. It is necessary to distinguish between pure credit risk and market risk. If you lend money to someone at a fixed interest rate (e.g., a standard bond), you bear only credit risk – i.e., the risk that the debtor will default. However, as soon as your return is, even partially, dependent on the economic performance of the underlying asset (e.g., profit from renting real estate), you assume market risk. And that is precisely when your model enters the dangerous zone of collective investment regulation.
At ARROWS, we analyze our clients' business models daily with respect to these three criteria. Our legal opinions provide a clear answer as to whether your project is in the safe zone or whether it requires adjustment to avoid issues.
Which business models are under the CNB's microscope?
The theoretical definition takes on real shape when looking at specific cases that the CNB has dealt with in recent years. Among the riskiest models are:
Crowdfunding and participation agreements: Typically, such a platform gathers funds from thousands of small investors, offering them a share in real estate rental yields. Although this is an innovative model, the CNB may evaluate it as an unlicensed fund if all three criteria are met: gathering money from the public, joint investment, and returns dependent on market risk. The assessment will not change even if the activity is formally split between two or more interconnected companies.
Unregulated "mini-funds" under Section 15 of ZISIF: This section allows for a simplified form of asset management, but with a key limitation - it is strictly forbidden to offer investments in such a structure to the public. Abuse of this instrument can lead to fraudulent schemes and huge losses for investors.
Corporate bond issues: Issuing bonds is a legitimate financing tool. However, it can cross the line and be considered unauthorized deposit-taking (so-called shadow banking) if it becomes the primary or sole activity of the company and the funds obtained are systematically used, for example, to provide loans to third parties.
Financial influencers ("Finfluencers"): The CNB is increasingly warning about the risks associated with influencers who may, often unknowingly, promote unregulated and risky investment products, thereby aiding the activities of unlicensed funds.
Our team at ARROWS has extensive experience in preparing and reviewing documentation for all these models. Whether you are preparing a crowdfunding campaign or a bond issue, we will ensure that your documentation and processes comply with regulations and protect you from sanctions.
Risky business models
Potential issues | How ARROWS helps (consultation@arws.cz) |
|---|---|
Crowdfunding platform with real estate participations: risk of meeting all three criteria of an unlicensed fund, fine up to CZK 150 million, dissolution of the company. | What we do: we prepare a legal opinion and propose adjustments to the model (e.g., transition to a regulated FKI). |
"Yield" bonds to finance a development project: yield tied to the success of the project and offered to a wider circle of people. | What we do: we prepare the terms of issue as a standard debt instrument or recommend a safer structure. |
"Mini-fund" under Section 15 of ZISIF with a public offering: direct violation of the law, risk of sanctions and criminal prosecution. | What we do: we help transition to a fully regulated fund. |
"Investors' Club" with an open membership: exceeding the public threshold, personal liability of the organizers. | What we do: we transform the club into a legal investment structure (FKI). |
P2P lending platform with transfer of market risk: could be an investment service or an unlicensed fund. | What we do: we assess the need for a license and manage the licensing process with the CNB. |
What are the actual sanctions? More than just a financial fine
The idea that a potential penalty from the CNB is just a "fine to be paid" is completely mistaken. The consequences are much deeper and often fatal for the entire business.
Financial sanctions: The law allows for a fine of up to CZK 150 million, or 10% of total annual turnover, or twice the amount of the unauthorized benefit obtained if these amounts exceed CZK 150 million. Such a sanction is liquidating for most companies.
Reputational and operational liquidation: The CNB has the right to order the publication of its decision. This immediately leads to a loss of trust among business partners, banks, and customers. Furthermore, the company and its management lose their so-called trustworthiness, which can prevent them from any future activity in the regulated financial market. In extreme cases, the CNB can propose the dissolution of the entire company to the court.
Criminal liability: This is the most serious risk. Operating an unlicensed fund constitutes unauthorized business activity, which, when carried out on a larger scale, can meet the definition of a criminal offense under Section 251 of the Criminal Code. This opens the way to personal criminal liability for directors, board members, and other persons involved in management.
Our goal at ARROWS is not just to solve problems when they arise, but above all to prevent them. Preparing robust legal documentation and setting up correct internal processes is the best protection against liquidating sanctions and criminal liability.
The Right Path: Fund of Qualified Investors (FKI) as a Safe and Strategic Tool
There is a legal, transparent, and strategically advantageous way to raise capital for ambitious projects: establishing a Fund of Qualified Investors (FKI). This is not just about defending against risks, but about choosing a professional and efficient structure that brings numerous benefits.
Security and trust: An FKI is a fully regulated and supervised entity. A key role is played by the depository (typically a reputable bank), which controls all cash flows and oversees the activities of the fund manager. This transparency and external control build immense trust among serious investors.
Investment flexibility: Unlike strictly bound retail funds, an FKI can invest in a very wide range of assets – from real estate, private equity, and startups to receivables, art, and cryptocurrencies. This allows for the implementation of unique investment strategies.
Extraordinary tax efficiency: This is one of the strongest arguments for an FKI. First, the income tax rate for the fund itself is only 5% instead of the standard 21% for corporations, provided the fund meets the conditions of a basic investment fund (Section 17b of the Income Tax Act). Second, for a Czech individual investor, income from the sale of a share in the fund is completely exempt from income tax after a three-year time test.
Legal access to capital: The FKI structure allows for legally and transparently approaching an unlimited number of so-called qualified investors, i.e., persons with sufficient capital and experience.
At ARROWS, we have helped establish and structure dozens of funds of qualified investors. We will guide you through the entire process – from the initial consultation and selection of the most suitable structure (e.g., the modern SICAV), through the preparation of all documentation and communication with the CNB, to connecting you with reputable investment companies and depositories.
Problems of an unregulated model
Potential issues | How ARROWS helps (consultation@arws.cz) |
|---|---|
Legal uncertainty: the model can be declared illegal at any time, risking fines, company dissolution, and criminal prosecution. | What we do: we secure the legal framework of an FKI as a legally approved and CNB-regulated structure. |
Limited growth: investments cannot be publicly offered, the circle of investors is small. | What we do: we prepare offering documents for qualified investors. |
Distrust of sophisticated investors: professionals avoid non-transparent structures. | What we do: we set up the statute, manager, and external control (depository, auditor). |
Personal liability of founders: liability for losses and violations of the law. | What we do: we structure the FKI to separate the fund's assets from the founders' assets. |
High tax burden: standard tax rate and additional taxation on distributions to investors. | What we do: we set up the fund with a 5% rate as a basic investment fund. |
How ARROWS Helps with International Expansion? The European Passport and the ARROWS International Network
Choosing a legal structure under Czech legislation is not just a local matter; it has a direct and fundamental impact on your international strategy. Indeed, the Czech ZISIF Act is an implementation of the pan-European Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD). This directive introduced a revolutionary tool known as the "European passport."
In practice, the European passport means that a fund whose manager obtains authorization in one EU member state can subsequently be marketed to professional investors in all other EU countries through a simple notification to the home regulator. You do not need to apply for a new license in Germany, Poland, or France. This opens up a single capital market to you. Conversely, an unregulated model confines you to the Czech market.
Furthermore, European regulation is constantly evolving. The new AIFMD 2.0 Directive brings further changes in areas such as liquidity management, loan origination by funds, or outsourcing. Staying compliant with this regulation is crucial.
ARROWS has a detailed understanding of European law and practical experience with cross-border transactions. We will help you not only with entering the European market but also ensure the smooth running of your international operations.
Conclusion
The path from an innovative idea to a successful project financed by external capital is full of challenges. However, the greatest of these may not be competition, but regulatory uncertainty. As we have shown, attempting to bypass the rules or operate in a presumed "grey zone" leads to a dead end full of risks, sanctions, and lost trust. Strategic legal structuring is the bridge that connects innovation and regulation.
A properly structured FKI transforms the regulatory burden into a powerful competitive advantage. It provides legal certainty, tax efficiency, credibility for investors, and a gateway to the European market.
At ARROWS, we are ready to be your partner on this journey. We provide comprehensive services, including drafting internal guidelines, preparing complete documentation for the CNB, representation in licensing proceedings, contract reviews, obtaining necessary permits, and professional training for management, including certification.
We pride ourselves on speed, high quality, and building long-term relationships. Our experience working for more than 150 joint-stock companies, 250 limited liability companies, and 51 municipalities and regions allows us not only to provide top-tier legal services, but also to connect our clients with interesting business and investment opportunities. We are also keen to hear your business ideas.
Do you have an ambitious project and are looking for capital? Do not risk the future of your business in regulatory uncertainty. Contact our team at ARROWS at consultation@arws.cz. We will be happy to discuss your plans and propose a safe and effective path to success.
About the author
Disclaimer:
The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and serves as a basic guide to the issue as of 2025. Although we strive for maximum accuracy, laws and their interpretation evolve over time. We are ARROWS Law Firm, a member of the Czech Bar Association (our supervisory authority), and for the maximum security of our clients, we are insured for professional liability with a limit of CZK 350,000,000. To verify the current wording of the regulations and their application to your specific situation, it is necessary to contact ARROWS Law Firm directly (consultation@arws.cz). We are not liable for any damages arising from the independent use of the information in this article without prior individual legal consultation.


