Interrupted Causation in Legal Practice

Damage in Your Company? You Are Not Always to Blame
For your company to be held liable for damages under Czech legislation, three basic prerequisites must be met. If even one of them is missing, the claim for damages will not stand:
Unlawful conduct: breach of a duty stipulated by contract or by law.
Occurrence of damage: actual material or non-material harm.
Causal link (causal nexus): the connection between the unlawful conduct and the occurrence of damage.
Example: a supplier delivers a defective part that damages your production machine. But for the defective part, the damage to the machine would not have occurred – the causal link here is obvious. Therefore, when assessing any claim, our Prague-based legal team first analyzes whether all three prerequisites are met at all. This approach often reveals weaknesses in the opposing party's claim even before court proceedings begin.
A Key Defense Mechanism: What Is a Broken Causal Link?
Even if all conditions of liability seem to be met, there is a strong defense argument that can completely release your company from liability: proving that the causal link was broken.
When a New, Decisive Cause Comes into Play
An interruption occurs when a new fact enters the chain of events, acting as the sole and independent cause of the damage, regardless of the original harmful event. The term novus actus interveniens is used internationally for this phenomenon. It can be the act of a third party, an act of force majeure, or even the conduct of the injured party themselves.
Beware of Confusion: A Broken Link Is Not the Same as Contributory Negligence
If the new event only contributes to the occurrence of the damage, but the original cause remains relevant, it is not a broken causal link. In such a case, your liability may be reduced, but it is not extinguished.
Correctly assessing this boundary is crucial – it decides between a complete release from liability and a mere reduction of damages.
When Does Someone Else's Mistake or Coincidence Work in Your Favor? Practical Examples
If your employees fail to detect a subsoil defect caused by a previous supplier, even though they should have under professional care, the court is more likely to assess the insufficient inspection as contributory negligence. If, on the other hand, you deliver flawless material that is subsequently damaged by the carrier due to improper storage, the carrier's conduct may be the new cause that breaks the causal link between your delivery and the damage.
Third-Party Intervention – From an Authority to a Hacker
In one case from case law, a herd of cattle escaped from an agricultural enterprise and caused an accident on a highway. The owner defended themselves by claiming that the police and firefighters did not act quickly enough. However, the court ruled that their alleged inaction was not the sole cause of the damage – the escape of the animals remained the primary cause.
A modern equivalent is a cyberattack on a cloud service provider, resulting in the leak of your clients' data. Whether such an attack breaks the causal link is a complex question requiring individual assessment – which is why it pays to address liability in advance in contracts with IT suppliers.
When the Injured Party Contributes to the Damage Themselves
The conduct of the injured party can be assessed as contributory negligence, or – in extreme cases – as a new sole cause. For example, if you deliver a machine with clear instructions and the customer uses it in violation of them, their conduct can significantly reduce or even exclude your liability. Proving such facts requires careful preparation and evidence.
Most Common Risks and Their Solutions
Potential Problems | How ARROWS Helps (consultation@arws.cz) |
|---|---|
Accusations of damage caused by a third party: costly disputes and reputational damage. | What we will do: represent you in court to prove a broken causal link. |
Defect in work caused by the client's instruction or material: repair costs and contractual penalties. | What we will do: review contracts for work and prepare documentation on fulfilling the duty to warn. |
Employee excess: dispute over whether the company or the employee is liable. | What we will do: prepare internal guidelines and train employees. |
Force majeure or cyberattack: liability disputes and regulatory fines. | What we will do: assess the impact of the event and address risks in contracts with IT suppliers. |
Intervention by a state authority: lost profits and damage to business relationships. | What we will do: claim compensation for damage caused by incorrect official procedure. |
International Trade and Cross-Border Disputes
In disputes with an international element, the court must first determine under which country's law the case will be assessed. For non-contractual obligations in the EU, this is governed primarily by the Rome II Regulation, according to which the law of the country where the damage occurred generally applies. In business relationships, the parties can choose the governing law in advance in the contract, which is a crucial risk management tool. Thanks to the ARROWS International network, we provide defense in cross-border disputes as well.
Summary
Liability for damages is an area full of nuances, where a single detail can decide a dispute worth millions of crowns. A broken causal link is a powerful defense tool, but it must be correctly distinguished from contributory negligence and supported by evidence.
Are you facing a claim for damages, or do you want to address risks in advance in your contracts? Write to us at consultation@arws.cz.
About the author
Disclaimer:
The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and serves as a basic guide to the issue as of 2026. Although we strive for maximum accuracy, laws and their interpretation evolve over time. We are ARROWS Law Firm, a member of the Czech Bar Association (our supervisory authority), and for the maximum security of our clients, we are insured for professional liability with a limit of CZK 350,000,000. To verify the current wording of the regulations and their application to your specific situation, it is necessary to contact ARROWS Law Firm directly (consultation@arws.cz). We are not liable for any damages arising from the independent use of the information in this article without prior individual legal consultation.

