Skip to content

Legal Disputes in Social Services: A Guide for Providers

Mgr. Jan Pavlík
Published:Updated:
Na obrázku vidíte advokáta poskytujícího právní pomoc poskytovatelům sociálních služeb.

Risk No. 1: Lawsuit by a client. When the quality of care is under court scrutiny

Clients and their family members are increasingly aware of their rights and are willing to assert them by all available means, including legal action. It is not just about financial compensation; your reputation is also at stake. Even an unsuccessful lawsuit can permanently damage public trust in your facility.

What is a non lege artis procedure in social services?

Legal theory requires providers to act lege artis – i.e., with due professional care, according to the rules of their field. In social services, this means complying not only with the law, but also with internal procedures and binding quality standards.

A fundamental shift in case law that you need to know about was brought by a recent ruling of the Czech Constitutional Court (case ref. III. US 176/24). Previously, a successful lawsuit required proving a direct and almost 100% causal link between your error and the deterioration of the client's condition.

This has changed. Courts now state that even a mere reduction in the chance of recovery or a better condition, caused by a non lege artis procedure, is in itself an infringement of the client's personal rights. A client can thus sue you for non-material damage, even if you prove that their condition was very serious and the outcome would have been uncertain even with the correct procedure.

For your management, this means you must defend yourself not only against claims for personal injury damages, but also against claims for the protection of personal rights, which are easier for the client to prove. The ARROWS Czech legal team will guide you through the court proceedings and prepare arguments reflecting the latest developments in case law regarding non lege artis procedures.

DO YOU NEED LEGAL HELP?

Get in touch — we're happy to help.

ARROWS law firm

You have insurance, but is it enough?

The Act on Social Services (Section 80) under Czech legislation imposes an obligation to have liability insurance for damage caused during the provision of social services. However, many providers mistakenly believe that this resolves all risks.

Unfortunately, the reality is different. Analyses and legal studies warn that compensation for personal injury in court disputes can reach "tens of millions of CZK". Your contracted insurance limits may be far from sufficient to cover such damage.

In addition, the insurance company may reduce or completely refuse payment if it finds that you have breached your legal obligations. Typically, if it finds that you do not have properly maintained documentation or correctly set up internal working procedures and guidelines.

We provide legal audits of insurance policies for our clients and help set up internal documentation to comply with the law. By doing so, we ensure maximum protection and prevent disputes over full coverage from the insurance company in the event of a problem.

Related questions on liability towards clients

1. What if an accident (fall) occurs despite all our care?

You are liable on the principle of so-called strict liability, i.e., for the outcome, not just for fault. The key is to prove in court that you did absolutely everything you could (complied with standards, assessed the client's risks). Properly maintained documentation is your only evidence.

2. What role does the contract with the client play?

A crucial one. The contract must clearly define the scope of services, as well as the rights and obligations of both parties. It must not contain provisions that would disproportionately curtail the client's rights. Reviewing contracts is fundamental prevention.

3. Can the family sue us for mistreatment even if the client themselves is satisfied?

Yes, family members may in certain cases (typically protection of personal rights or asserting claims after a deceased person) have the right to file a lawsuit. Proper communication, setting up processes, and precise documentation are key in these cases.
ARROWS law firm

Lawsuits by clients

Possible problems

How ARROWS helps (consultation@arws.cz)

Lawsuit for damages for a client's fall or personal injury: payments in the range of hundreds of thousands to millions of CZK.

What we will do: we will represent you in court and in out-of-court negotiations.

Lawsuit for the protection of personal rights due to a non lege artis procedure: high financial satisfaction.

What we will do: we will prepare a liability opinion and a defense strategy.

Challenging the validity of the contract: on the provision of services or parts thereof.

What we will do: we will prepare or review the contractual documentation.

Breach of confidentiality obligation: under Section 100 of the Act on Social Services.

What we will do: we will draft guidelines for handling sensitive data and train employees.

ARROWS law firm

Risk No. 2: Administrative proceedings. When a fine or loss of registration is threatened

Court disputes with clients are not the only threat. Perhaps even more serious and frequent are administrative proceedings, audits, and inspections. These are primarily carried out by regional authorities and the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs (MoLSA).

The result of an inspection can be not only a high fine, but also the imposition of mandatory corrective measures (which cost time and money) or, in extreme cases, the initiation of proceedings to revoke registration.

Inspections focus on your documentation

Inspections do not just check hygiene or staffing levels. They focus on compliance with the so-called quality standards of social services. Here, it is crucial to realize that inspectors evaluate so-called "essential criteria".

These criteria include, for example, the obligation to have written working procedures (Criterion 1c) or internal rules for protecting individuals from violations of their rights (Criterion 2a). For facility directors, this means that internal guidelines are not just bureaucracy, but a crucial criterion for a successful inspection.

If these documents are missing, outdated, or not understood by employees in practice, it constitutes an administrative offense. This carries a fine, for example, up to CZK 50,000 just for failing to submit the required data on time. Our Prague-based legal team will prepare a complete set of internal guidelines and documents required by law that will stand up to any inspection.

Case Law: Is there a risk of registration revocation due to debts?

One of the greatest risks for providers is registration revocation proceedings. Administrative authorities sometimes act very strictly and formalistically. In a recent landmark case (case ref. 8 Ads 90/2024), a regional authority attempted to revoke the registration of a provider (HVĚZDA, z. ú.). The reason was that after the registration was granted, the provider incurred a social security debt of over CZK 6 million.

Although the provider had agreed on an installment plan, the authorities insisted on revocation. The case went all the way to the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC). It ruled that subsequently incurred arrears (i.e., those that arose only after obtaining registration) are not grounds for revoking registration under Section 82(3)(a) of the Act on Social Services.

This judgment is crucial for providers in temporary financial difficulties. It shows that authorities can act unlawfully. Knowledge of this case law gives ARROWS attorneys strong arguments when representing clients in administrative proceedings against regional authorities or the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs. We defend the rights of providers based on the most up-to-date court decisions.

Administrative proceedings and inspections

Possible problems

How ARROWS helps (consultation@arws.cz)

Fine from the MoLSA inspection: for non-compliance with quality standards or missing internal rules.

What we will do: we will draft internal guidelines and working procedures.

Administrative proceedings regarding an administrative offense: e.g., for failing to notify changes in registration.

What we will do: we will represent you before administrative authorities.

Threat of registration revocation: due to (even alleged) breach of law.

What we will do: we will use all legal means to preserve your registration.

Need to obtain new permits: for expanding services.

What we will do: we will ensure a smooth permitting process.

ARROWS law firm

Risk No. 3: Disputes with employees. Who bears the responsibility?

The operation of social services relies on people. This inevitably brings labor law risks. It is not just about common disputes over the invalidity of termination or wage claims. A specific and very serious risk is liability for occupational accidents, which often take a tragic form in social services.

Occupational accident: When a client attacks an employee

Work in social services is mentally and physically demanding. Unfortunately, physical assault on a worker by a client is not exceptional. From a legal perspective, this is an occupational accident. Here we encounter a specific problem.

Analysis of case law shows that the employer (provider) is liable for an employee's occupational accident, even if it was caused by a third party – typically an aggressive client. This is strict liability of the employer; you are responsible for the outcome (injury), even if you as management did not make a direct error.

However, the real problem arises in the compensation process. Case law reveals a common scenario:

  1. An employee is attacked by a client and injured.

  2. The employer (you) recognizes the injury as occupational.

  3. Your statutory insurance company (with which you are insured for occupational accident liability) refuses to pay.

  4. In order to obtain compensation, the employee must sue you (their employer), not the insurance company.

Paradoxically, you have to face a lawsuit from your own employee, even though you stand on their side against the insurance company.

This creates an extremely toxic working environment and puts you in the role of the "enemy". Our role at ARROWS does not consist only of defending you against an employee's lawsuit. We will take over negotiations with the insurance company on your behalf and help you set up internal OHS (occupational health and safety) processes to minimize risks.

We also organize professional training for employees or management (including a certificate) on how to proceed legally and correctly in crisis situations, including client assaults.

Related questions on labor disputes

1. What if an employee does not meet the qualifications under the Act on Social Services?

This can be grounds for termination for failing to meet the requirements set by legal regulations. However, it must be given legitimately and formally correctly. An invalid termination can cost you hundreds of thousands in back pay.

2. What about employing foreigners?

Employing foreigners brings specific obligations. You must report vacancies to the Labour Office and keep precise records of employees and their residence permits. An administrative error can be classified as illegal employment, carrying a fine of up to CZK 10 million.

DO YOU HAVE MORE QUESTIONS? GET IN TOUCH

ARROWS law firm

Do you have branches abroad or employ foreigners?

The social services sector is becoming increasingly internationalized. Whether it is the cross-border provision of services within the EU or addressing staff shortages by employing foreigners from third countries.

Thanks to our ARROWS International network, built over ten years, we handle cases with an international element practically every day. We will provide you with a complete legal service in obtaining work permits, set up contracts with seconded workers, and protect you from draconian fines for illegal employment.

Final Summary

As all three main risks show, a reactive approach – solving problems only in court – is extremely expensive and reputationally risky. The key to the sustainable operation of social services is precise legal prevention.

Our experience, based on long-term cooperation with our clients (our portfolio includes more than 150 joint-stock companies and 250 LLCs), guarantees speed and high quality.

We offer a comprehensive legal prevention package for social service providers:

  • Audit and preparation of contractual documentation with clients.

  • Drafting of internal guidelines and working procedures to meet quality standards.

  • Complete labor law agenda (contracts, OHS guidelines).

  • Legal consultations that protect against fines and inspections.

  • Representation in courts and before administrative authorities.

  • Professional training for employees or management, including a certificate.

We pride ourselves on speed and high quality. Contact us at consultation@arws.cz to get a tailored legal solution for your organization. Furthermore, we actively seek business opportunities for our clients and are happy to connect them. If you have an interesting business idea or investment opportunity, we would love to hear it.

Frequently asked questions about litigation in social services

1. What is the difference between a client complaint and a lawsuit?

A complaint is a submission that you, as a provider, handle internally. You have a legal obligation to have a process for handling them, including a 30-day deadline, which can be extended by another 30 days. A lawsuit is a filing with a court that initiates a legal dispute. Proper and professional handling of a complaint can prevent a lawsuit.

2. Can a client sue us even if they signed a contract with clearly defined terms?

Yes. A contract cannot exclude liability for personal injury or infringement of personal rights. If a provision in your contract contradicts the law (e.g., limits the client's rights), it is invalid. The court will always examine the actual provision of care, not just the text of the contract.

3. What documents do we primarily need to have prepared for a MoLSA inspection?

The inspection will focus on registration documents, contracts with clients, and especially written quality standards. This includes working procedures, rules for handling complaints, and procedures for protecting clients' rights.

4. What is an "omitted evidence" and why is it important?

This is a procedural error by the court. If the court, without justification, fails to examine evidence proposed by you (e.g., a key care record, employee testimony), it renders its decision defective. Such a decision can be challenged.

5. Can we refuse to enter into a contract with a "problematic" applicant?

You can only refuse an applicant for statutory reasons: you do not provide the service they request; you do not have sufficient capacity; or their health condition rules out the provision of a residential service (e.g., they require inpatient care in a medical facility or have an acute infectious disease). Other reasons are considered discriminatory.

6. What if the client turns directly to the ombudsman with a complaint?

The Public Defender of Rights (ombudsman) can investigate the conduct of authorities (MoLSA), but also of private facilities if there is a suspicion of discrimination or mistreatment. Their investigation is a serious reputational matter. It is always better to have your own internal processes so robust that the client has no reason to turn elsewhere.

Next steps

Every situation is different and the right approach depends on the details. Tell us what you are dealing with – an ARROWS specialist will get back to you within 24 hours, assess your situation and propose the next steps.

About the author

Mgr. Jan Pavlík
Mgr. Jan Pavlík

Associate

Jan Pavlík is a lawyer who helps companies and entrepreneurs in situations where law meets day-to-day operations, money and people. He works at the ARROWS law firm in its Hradec Králové office and focuses on employment law, corporate law, commercial and court disputes and contract practice. He also handles real estate transactions and environmental law.

Disclaimer:

The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and serves as a basic guide to the issue as of 2026. Although we strive for maximum accuracy, laws and their interpretation evolve over time. We are ARROWS Law Firm, a member of the Czech Bar Association (our supervisory authority), and for the maximum security of our clients, we are insured for professional liability with a limit of CZK 350,000,000. To verify the current wording of the regulations and their application to your specific situation, it is necessary to contact ARROWS Law Firm directly (consultation@arws.cz). We are not liable for any damages arising from the independent use of the information in this article without prior individual legal consultation.

Facing a similar situation?

We will get back to you within 24 hours.

Your case will be handled by:Mgr. Jan Pavlíkassociate

I agree to the processing of personal data.