Sale of Assets and VAT

The Line Between Opportunity and Tax Risk

Incorrect tax assessment of an asset sale can lead to a VAT reassessment, high interest penalties, and significant fines that can reach hundreds of thousands or even half a million Czech crowns. The legal handling of the transaction, including determining whether it constitutes an economic activity, is therefore absolutely essential.

The law firm ARROWS has twenty years of experience in resolving these complex tax disputes and provides legal consultations that protect clients from fines and audits. Our lawyers are ready to help you define your activity, prepare legal opinions, and secure your transaction with maximum legal certainty—write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

Defining a Taxable Transaction: When Does a Sale Become a Systematic Economic Activity?

The Act on Value Added Tax (VAT Act) in Section 5(3) defines economic activity quite broadly as the systematic activity of producers, traders, and persons providing services for the purpose of obtaining income. Business owners and investors who sell assets (e.g., land or machinery they have held for years) often automatically assume it is a one-off, non-taxable activity.

However, this view may not hold up before the tax authorities. Established case law of the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) interprets the concept of economic activity very broadly. It includes any systematic activity carried out with the intention of generating regular income, including the preparatory phase that precedes the sale itself.

The tax authorities do not primarily assess only the number of transactions (frequency), but rather the intention behind the acquisition of the asset and its preparation for sale. If a company acquires land, actively improves its value (e.g., by preparing project documentation or installing utility networks), and then sells it, the Tax Authority may retroactively conclude that from the outset, the intention was to achieve a regular return, typical for a trader. In such a case, even a single sale becomes a taxable supply.

It is critical for clients to have a strong legal opinion that documents the original purpose of the asset and defines the transaction in a way that minimizes the risk of retroactive reclassification by the Tax Authority. Our lawyers are ready to help you prepare a legal opinion and an analysis of the VAT implications—write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

You can read more about this service HERE.

Criteria for Assessing the Systematic Nature of an Activity

Strong indicators of systematic activity include, for example, selling assets repeatedly in a short period, where the sale of three apartments within a year is a clear signal of business activity. The use of tangible and intangible assets for the purpose of obtaining income is also considered an economic activity if these assets are used systematically.

In practice, this issue is more complex than it first appears. While an entrepreneur's intention to sell a long-term asset may change over time, the tax office focuses on objective evidence of the preparatory phase and active marketing. This game of tax risks is too costly to be left to chance. The law firm ARROWS handles these matters daily, which can significantly save clients time and minimize the risk of errors.

Long-Term Assets and the Adjustment of Tax Deductions

Even if the sale of an asset is exempt from tax (i.e., it is not a taxable supply), another, highly technical obligation comes into play: the adjustment of tax deduction (Section 78 of the VAT Act).

Monitoring Input Tax Deduction for Long-Term Assets

For VAT purposes, a long-term asset is considered to be not only tangible property (including land, which is a long-term tangible asset), but also depreciable intangible assets and technical improvements.

If a claim for input tax deduction was made when acquiring this asset, the payer must monitor how the asset is used throughout the entire specified period. The period for adjusting the tax deduction is 5 years, but for immovable property, buildings and their technical improvements, and land, it is extended to 10 years.

The consequences of a sale are assessed in the context of a change in the purpose of the asset's use. A change in the scope of use occurs, for example, if the payer claimed a full tax deduction (100%) and subsequently uses the asset for purposes for which they are not entitled to a tax deduction, or are entitled only to a partial deduction.

A Practical Pitfall: One-Off Adjustment of Tax Deduction

The adjustment of the tax deduction is performed if the scope of the asset's use for purposes that establish the right to a tax deduction changes. The most common and riskiest trigger for this obligation is the sale of an asset under a VAT-exempt regime (i.e., the right to deduction is 0%) during the adjustment period. In such a case, the payer must return a proportional part of the originally claimed VAT to the state.

When selling a long-term asset within the adjustment period, this adjustment is made as a one-off in the tax period in which the sale occurred. The payer must be familiar with technical terms such as the proportional coefficient and the settlement coefficient, which are used for the precise calculation of the amount of tax to be returned.

It is important to realize that the deduction adjustment is only made if the difference between the original and new entitlement to the tax deduction is greater than 10 percentage points. Despite this tolerance threshold, the process is so complex that it requires deep knowledge of the subject matter.

If a client sells an asset and overlooks this obligation, the tax authorities will retroactively assess the VAT along with penalties. Our lawyers are insured for damages up to CZK 500,000,000. It is therefore safer for the client to have the calculation and preparation of the documentation for the tax deduction adjustment professionally handled. Contact us at konzultace@arws.cz to get a tailor-made legal solution, including the preparation of documents required by law.

Specific Risks for Real Estate and Technical Improvements

The sale of selected immovable property is exempt from VAT after a ten-year period from the first final building approval or from the completion of a significant technical improvement (TI). However, VAT payers have the option, even within this period, to sell the property under the VAT regime if the buyer is also a VAT payer.

The option to tax (which must be stipulated in the purchase agreement) is strategically important, as it allows the seller to avoid the obligation to adjust the tax deduction (Section 78 of the VAT Act) if they claimed a full deduction upon acquisition or technical improvement.

A major risk is the incorrect classification of interventions in the property. Many investors mistakenly classify an extensive renovation as a routine repair instead of a Technical Improvement (TI), which changes the purpose or technical parameters of the asset. Misclassifying a TI triggers a domino effect: it affects income tax (a TI is depreciated) and, crucially for VAT, extends the ten-year period for VAT upon sale. This creates a risk of a VAT reassessment and a penalty of 20% of the assessed tax.

In practice, this legal issue is more complex than it first appears. A layperson often does not see the hidden exceptions, procedural details, connections to other regulations, and risks. Therefore, a professional review is necessary. Preparing internal guidelines, compiling documentation, and providing legal consultations that protect against fines and audits are part of our daily agenda. For an immediate solution to your situation, write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

International Asset Sales: Mandatory Registration Abroad

Corporations and investors with international assets must be careful to determine the place of supply. When selling immovable property (or services related to it), the place of supply is always in the state where the immovable property is located.

If a Czech company sells property in another EU member state, it must handle VAT according to that state's local legislation. In many cases, this means an obligation to register for VAT in that country and file local tax returns.

Thanks to the ARROWS International network, built over ten years, and our almost daily handling of cases with an international element, the law firm ARROWS ensures the correct determination of the tax regime and the fulfillment of all local registration obligations. Do you need legal assistance abroad? Write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

More Complex Corporate Scenarios: Transfer of a Business as a Safe Solution

When selling complex packages of assets, it is essential to distinguish between the sale of individual items and the transfer of a business. The sale of a business (or its independently functioning part) is not subject to VAT.

Confusing these regimes has enormous consequences. If a transaction that should be a transfer of a business is mistakenly treated as a taxable sale of real estate, it creates a huge risk for the buyer. In the event of a retroactive reclassification by the Tax Authority, it will be found that the buyer unlawfully claimed a VAT deduction. The buyer must return the VAT to the tax administrator and face penalties, even though the seller (who incorrectly paid the tax) can claim a refund.

This creates immense legal uncertainty. For a transaction to qualify as a transfer of a business, it is necessary to ensure accounting and organizational continuity—the transferred part must be independently functional even after the transfer. Furthermore, it is essential to precisely define the subject of the transfer in the contract and not to forget publication obligations (e.g., publishing the transfer in the Collection of Deeds).

The law firm ARROWS deals with this agenda daily and can precisely prepare or review all contracts to minimize the risk of a retroactive tax assessment. Experienced lawyers thus protect both the seller and the buyer from financial and legal disputes. Do not hesitate to contact our firm at konzultace@arws.cz. Comprehensive Solutions for Corporate Clients

With our experience from providing long-term services to more than 150 joint-stock companies and 250 limited liability companies, we deliver fast and high-quality services. We understand that in complex transactions involving the transfer of a business, every detail of the contract and tax documentation must be absolutely precise.

ARROWS is insured for damages up to CZK 500,000,000. Securing the transaction is therefore safer for the client when handled professionally. We regularly partner with in-house corporate lawyers to resolve special matters, such as preparing or reviewing contracts for the transfer of a business. Our lawyers are ready to help you prepare or review contracts for the transfer of a business—write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

High-Risk Situations and Penalties

An incorrect assessment of the VAT regime for an asset sale has an immediate impact on cash flow. If the tax authorities reassess the tax, there is an automatic penalty of 20% of the assessed tax. In addition to the penalty for the tax assessment, high procedural fines are also imposed. Failure to comply with obligations related to the VAT control statement (KH) can result in fixed fines (from CZK 1,000 to 50,000).

Particularly risky is the imposition of a fine of up to CZK 500,000 if the payer, by failing to comply with an obligation related to the VAT control statement, seriously obstructs or frustrates the administration of taxes. This penalty cannot be waived and is typically applied in cases of serious or repeated errors, often associated with the incorrect reporting of an asset sale or an omitted deduction adjustment.

From an investor's or CFO's perspective, the risk of fines up to CZK 500,000 and a 20% penalty on the assessed tax represents a significant threat to capital. Legally securing the transaction, including the preparation of documentation that protects against fines and penalties, is therefore a necessity. 

The law firm ARROWS handles these matters daily, which can significantly save clients time and minimize the risk of errors. To minimize the risk of errors and fines, entrust these matters to professionals. Our lawyers are ready to help you—write to us at konzultace@arws.cz. 

Conclusion: Secure Management of Corporate Assets with ARROWS

The legal issues surrounding the sale of corporate assets in relation to VAT are complex, technical, and burdened by CJEU case law that broadens the definition of taxable activity. Matters such as the correct determination of economic activity, the precise calculation of the tax deduction adjustment, and the strategic decision on the tax regime for real estate require deep expertise.

The law firm ARROWS is the ideal partner to secure your transactions. We handle these matters daily, which allows us to significantly save clients time and minimize the risk of errors. Our experience from providing long-term services to more than 150 joint-stock companies and 250 limited liability companies is a guarantee of speed and high quality.

Beyond legal services: If you have interesting investment or business opportunities, we can connect clients with each other within our broad network. We are also happy to listen to your entrepreneurial or business ideas.

If you do not want to risk errors, penalties, tax assessments, or disputes with the tax authorities, you can safely entrust the entire matter to the law firm ARROWS. For comprehensive support in the sale of your assets and protection from VAT risks, contact us today at konzultace@arws.cz.