Skip to content

Stay of execution on the basis of the fiction of the beneficiary's consent From the viewpoint of the Supreme Court

Omission of the beneficiary need not mean permanent loss of the claim

Termination of enforcement proceedings based on the creditor’s deemed consent does not necessarily mean that the debt can never be recovered. The Czech Supreme Court confirmed that such termination does not create a res judicata barrier preventing a new enforcement application based on the same title. The article explains when proceedings may be restarted and why creditors should still respond to enforcement notices promptly.

Legal experts discussing beneficiary consent and Supreme Court perspectives on claim retention.

How does the fiction of the beneficiary's consent work?

Supreme Court: the bar of rei iudicatae does not apply

The lower courts initially stopped the second execution because they considered it inadmissible due to the existence of the res judicata bar. However, the Supreme Court has taken the view that a decision to stay the execution on the basis of the fiction of consent is not a substantive decision on the existence of a claim and that , therefore, the execution proceedings may be reopened on the basis of the same enforcement order.

Key arguments of the Supreme Court

  • There was no real (substantive) review of the justification for the suspension of the execution, the bailiff decided only on the basis of the fiction of consent.
  • The right holder could lose his claim only because of a formal error, which would constitute a manifest injustice bordering on the rule of law.
  • There is no reason to exclude completely the possibility for the creditor to reopen the execution.

Thus, the fiction of the consent of the beneficiary under Article 55(3) of the Enforcement Procedure Code does not constitute an obstacle to a final decision, in other words, the beneficiaries are not forever barred from recovering their claim simply because they did not respond to the bailiff's summons in the original enforcement proceedings,

Frequently asked questions on the fiction of the beneficiary's consent

1. When does the fiction of the beneficiary's consent to the stay of execution arise?

When the obligor files an application to stay the execution and the beneficiary fails to respond within the time limit to the bailiff's request as to whether it agrees with the application (Article 55(3) of the Enforcement Procedure Code). The bailiff then grants the application within 30 days of the expiry of the time limit for responding, without examining whether the obligor's assertions are true.

2. On what ground does the bailiff stay the execution when the beneficiary remains silent?

On the ground stated by the obligor in its application, typically that the debt has already been paid. The Supreme Court emphasised that it is this actual ground from the obligor's application that matters, not the formal ground the bailiff states in the decision, as bailiffs' practice differs in this respect.

3. Can the beneficiary appeal against a stay based on the fiction?

Yes, but the decision is in principle irreversible. An appeal can succeed on the merits only if the bailiff wrongly concluded that the fiction of consent had arisen. Whether the obligor actually paid the debt is no longer examined, because the beneficiary's silence rendered the obligor's assertions undisputed.

The impact on the beneficiaries

If the creditor fails to respond, the enforcement proceedings may end without any real review of the merits of the application for stay of execution.

If the execution has been stopped due to the fiction of consent, the beneficiary may propose to restart it. The Supreme Court makes it clear that such a decision does not create a bar to a final judgment.

However, it remains essential for the beneficiary to actively respond to the bailiff's calls during the execution.

The impact on the mandatory

For debtors, this means that if the execution has been stopped on the basis of this fiction, their situation may not be finally resolved. The Supreme Court has now made it clear that in such cases, there is no substantive decision on the discharge of the debt and the obligee can re-petition the enforcement of his claim.

Thus, the strategy of "waiting to see if the obligee responds" is not reliable in the long run.

Whether you are the obligee or the obligee, if you need help with foreclosure law, contact us to secure qualified legal protection!

Frequently asked questions on the stay of execution based on the fiction of consent

1. Can the beneficiary file a new enforcement application after the execution has been stayed on the basis of the fiction of consent?

Yes. In its resolution Ref. No. 20 Cdo 1604/2024, the Supreme Court held that such a decision does not create the res judicata bar, because no one reviewed the claim on the merits. The beneficiary may therefore initiate a new execution on the basis of the same enforcement order against the same obligor.

2. When, on the contrary, does the stay of a previous execution preclude a new one?

When the previous execution was stayed on a general ground that the court or the bailiff actually assessed, for example that the right was extinguished by performance (Section 268(1)(g) of the Code of Civil Procedure). Such a final decision prevents further execution between the same parties on the basis of the same order and for the same performance.

3. Does a new execution mean that the obligor will have to pay the debt again?

Not necessarily. In the new execution, the obligor may again apply for a stay, and this time the enforcement court will decide on the application after assessing it on the merits. If the obligor proves that the enforced claim has been extinguished, the court will stay the execution.

4. By when and where must the obligor file an application to stay the execution?

Within 15 days of the day on which it learned of the ground for the stay, with the bailiff conducting the execution (Article 55(1) of the Enforcement Procedure Code). The application must describe the facts relevant to its timeliness and support the assertions with documents, otherwise the bailiff will reject it.

5. What happens if the beneficiary disagrees with the stay of execution?

The beneficiary responds within the time limit to the obligor's assertions and submits documents refuting them. In such a case, the bailiff does not decide on the application itself but refers it, together with the enforcement file, to the enforcement court, which decides on the stay.

6. Can the execution also end if nothing is recovered in it for a long time?

Yes. If, within 6 years of the enforcement clause being recorded, there has not been even partial performance and no real estate is affected by the execution, the bailiff asks the beneficiary whether it agrees to the stay (Article 55(7) of the Enforcement Procedure Code). If the beneficiary agrees or remains silent for 30 days, the bailiff stays the execution; disagreement usually means a request to pay an advance for continuing the execution.

Disclaimer:

The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and serves as a basic guide to the issue as of 2026. Although we strive for maximum accuracy, laws and their interpretation evolve over time. We are ARROWS Law Firm, a member of the Czech Bar Association (our supervisory authority), and for the maximum security of our clients, we are insured for professional liability with a limit of CZK 350,000,000. To verify the current wording of the regulations and their application to your specific situation, it is necessary to contact ARROWS Law Firm directly (consultation@arws.cz). We are not liable for any damages arising from the independent use of the information in this article without prior individual legal consultation.

Facing a similar situation?

We will get back to you within 24 hours.

Your case will be handled by:JUDr. Jakub Dohnal, Ph.D., LL.M.associate, managing partner

I agree to the processing of personal data.